Agents

Insurance agent with young couple
Call STAR Insurance
A licensed insurance agent is available to help you with your needs.


1-800-321-9633

Your valuables. Our values.
With STAR Insurance, you're covered.


Our invaluable personal service is above and beyond anything you'll find … it's what makes us stand out from the competition and why our customers won't go anywhere else. Find an agent in your area below.




John Lefever Headshot John Lefever
President & CEO - STAR Insurance

102 W. Van Buren
Columbia City, IN 46725
(260) 248-6088


Lyndsey Bannon headshot Lyndsey Bannon
Account Executive

403 Parkview Drive
New Castle, IN 47362
(765) 593-5130


Nicole Carrol Headshot Nicole Carroll
Account Executive

105 N. Main Street
Bluffton, IN 46714
(260) 824-3620


Lisa Claypool Headshot Lisa Claypool
Life & Health Specialist

105 Frontage Road
Columbia City, IN 46725
(260) 248-6075


Mark Coonrod Headshot Mark Coonrod
Account Executive

111 N. Main Street
Churubusco, IN 46723
(260) 467-5670


Jena Crouch Headshot Jena Crouch
Account Executive

1708 E. Markland Avenue
Kokomo, IN 46902
(765) 868-3855

315 S. Adams Street
Marion IN 46952
(765) 651-6850


Heidi Darley Headshot Heidi Darley
Benefits Consultant

105 Frontage Road
Columbia City, IN 46725
(260) 248-6027


Billy Davenport Headshot Billy Davenport
Account Executive

2130 E. Dupont Road
Fort Wayne, IN 46825
(260) 467-5688


Leslee Derbeck Headshot Leslee Derbeck
Account Manager, Employee Benefits

105 Frontage Road
Columbia City, IN 46725
(260) 248-6075


Terry Diller
Account Executive

2130 E. Dupont Road
Fort Wayne, IN 46825
(260) 467-5690


Trent Diller Headshot Trent Diller
Account Executive

2130 E. Dupont Road
Fort Wayne, IN 46825
(260) 467-5692


Layne Fulk Headshot Layne Fulk
Account Executive

111 N. Main Street
Churubusco, IN 46723
(260) 467-5670


Hope German Headshot Hope German
Account Executive

360 W. North Street
Kendallville, IN 46755
(260) 349-3730


Savanah Gibson Headshot Savanah Gibson
Account Executive

403 Parkview Drive
New Castle, IN 47362
(765) 593-5127


Brent Hickman Headshot Brent Hickman
Account Executive

1708 E. Markland Avenue
Kokomo, IN 46902
(765) 868-3855


315 S. Adams Street
Marion, IN 46952
(765) 651-6800


Allen Howard Headshot Allen Howard
Benefits Consultant

127 W. Berry Street
Fort Wayne, IN 46802
(260) 467-5556


Cassie Jone Headshot

Cassie Jones
Account Executive

102 W. Van Buren
Columbia City, IN 46725
(260) 248-6088


Todd Jones Headshot Todd Jones
Account Executive

207 S. State Street
South Whitley, IN 46787
(260) 248-6060


Chuck Kennedy Headshot Chuck Kennedy
Account Executive

400 Frontage Road
Huntington, IN 46750
(260) 356-3313


Shelby Longebaugh Headshot Shelby Longenbaugh
Account Executive

102 W. Van Buren
Columbia City, IN 46725
(260) 248-6088


Nick Medhikhan Headshot Nick Mehdikhan
Director of Benefits Division

102 W. Van Buren Street
Columbia City, IN 46725

(260) 248-6056


John Myer Headshot John Myer
Account Executive

3610 River Crossing Parkway, Suite 100
Indianapolis, IN 46240

(317) 566-7343


Kaylie Ritenour Headshot Kaylie Ritenour
Account Executive

400 N. High Street
Muncie, IN 47305
(765) 751-3583 


Lynn Smith Headshot Lynn Smith
Account Executive

2130 E. Dupont Road
Fort Wayne, IN 46825
(260) 467-5698


Scott Smith Headshots Scott Smith
Account Executive


105 N. Main Street
Bluftton, IN 46714
(260) 824-3620

155 N. First Street
Decatur, IN 46733
(260) 724-3111


Carolyn Snyder Headshot Carolyn Snyder
Account Executive

102 W. Van Buren
Columbia City, IN 46725
(260) 248-6088






Funds not insured by the FDIC, not deposits of, or guaranteed by, STAR Financial Bank or any of its affiliates; not insured by any federal government agency; subject to investment risk if the insurance has a cash value, including possible loss of the principle amount invested. Insurance products are made available through STAR Insurance Agency, Inc., a licensed insurance agency affiliate of SFB; insurance products are underwritten by, and are the obligations of, the insurance companies that issue the insurance policies; these insurance companies are not affiliated with SFB.