Find an Agent

Insurance agent with young couple
Call STAR Insurance
A licensed insurance agent is available to help you with your needs.


Your valuables. Our values.
With STAR Insurance, you're covered.

Our invaluable personal service is above and beyond anything you'll find … it's what makes us stand out from the competition and why our customers won't go anywhere else. Find an agent in your area below.

Todd Jones Headshot Todd Jones
President, STAR Insurance

102 W. Van Buren Street
Columbia City, IN 46725 

(260) 248-6060 

Billy Davenport Headshot Billy Davenport
Sales Manager - Insurance

2130 E. Dupont Road
Fort Wayne, IN 46825 

(260) 479-2511 x5699 

Leslee Derbeck Headshot Leslee Robinson
Benefits Director

105 Frontage Road
Columbia City, IN 46725

(260) 248-6088 x6073 

Heidi Darley Headshot Heidi Darley
Benefits Consultant

105 Frontage Road
Columbia City, IN 46725

(260) 248-6027 

Lyndsey Bannon headshot Lyndsey Bannon
Service Agent

9165 E. 56th Street
Indianapolis, IN 46216

(765) 593-5130 x3174 

Mark Coonrod Headshot Mark Coonrod
Account Executive

4070 N. US 33
Churubusco, IN 46723

(260) 467-5670 

Layne Fulk Headshot Layne Fulk
Account Executive

4070 N. US 33 
Churubusco, IN 46723

(260) 467-5670 

Hope German Headshot Hope German
Account Executive

2004 N. Wayne St.

Angola, IN 46703

(260) 349-3730 

Savanah Gibson
Account Executive

403 Parkview Drive
New Castle, IN 47362

(765) 593-5127 

Chuck Kennedy Headshot Chuck Kennedy
Senior Account Executive

400 Frontage Road
Huntington, IN 46750

(260) 356-3313 

Shelby Longebaugh Headshot Shelby Longenbaugh
Account Executive

102 W. Van Buren
Columbia City, IN 46725

(260) 248-6088 x6176 

Scott Smith Headshots Scott Smith
Account Executive

315 S. Adams Street
Marion, IN 46952

(765) 651-6849 

Nicole Carroll
Service Agent

(260) 724-3111 x6216 

Tara McBroom

Service Agent

315 S Adams St
Marion IN 46952

(765) 651-6850

Jessica Zaklikiewicz
Service Agent

1980 N. Main St., Suite A-2
Bluffton, IN 46714

(260) 824-3620 x6202

Funds not insured by the FDIC, not deposits of, or guaranteed by, STAR Financial Bank or any of its affiliates; not insured by any federal government agency; subject to investment risk if the insurance has a cash value, including possible loss of the principle amount invested. Insurance products are made available through STAR Insurance Agency, Inc., a licensed insurance agency affiliate of SFB; insurance products are underwritten by, and are the obligations of, the insurance companies that issue the insurance policies; these insurance companies are not affiliated with SFB.